Thursday, November 19, 2026
snpick
Analysis

Islamic Extremism and U.S. Foreign Policy: What the Evidence Shows

a
admin
October 22, 2026 • Updated 6:28 AM • 8 min read
Islamic Extremism
Illustration: snpick

Islamic Extremism and U.S. Foreign Policy: What Hillary Clinton Admitted and What the Evidence Shows

In April 2009 Hillary Clinton sat in front of a House subcommittee. Made a statement that Washington rarely says aloud. She spoke about Pakistan and the militants troubling Pakistan. She explained that the fighters the U.S. Was confronting that day had received financial support from the U.S. Two decades earlier. I was surprised to hear that. Her exact words were “the people we are fighting today, we funded 20 years ago.” She was the Secretary of State, and she was describing an American policy, not repeating a rumor.

That remark is the best doorway into a question many Muslims, and many people outside the Muslim world, keep circling. Is Islamic extremism mostly the product of Muslim choices, or is it closer to a long-running American project that Muslims have ended up paying for? This post makes the case for the second reading as strongly as the record allows, then checks where that case holds and where it runs out. I also try to answer the harder questions that follow from it, including why the Muslim world has struggled to respond, what the science and education numbers say, and what a way out might look like.

What Clinton actually said about Islamic Extremism, and what she did not

The internet has a habit of improving on good quotes. Clips of Clinton circulate with captions claiming Clinton said “we created al-Qaeda” or Clinton claims that the U.S. Built ISIS. Fact‑checkers at Snopes, Vox Ukraine and others looked at those clips. Found Clinton never said the first claim, that the footage is from 2009 not 2011 and that the claim about ISIS is attached to a clip, about Pakistan. One viral translation turned “funded” into “founded ” which is a claim entirely.

So here is what the record supports. In that 2009 hearing she said the U.S. went into Pakistan to fight the Soviets, worked through Pakistan’s intelligence agency (the ISI) to recruit mujahideen, and was happy to let fighters arrive from Saudi Arabia carrying their Wahhabi brand of Islam, because the goal was beating the Soviet Union. Then, she said, the U.S. left Pakistan with the Stingers and the landmines and sanctioned it. Dawn reported her remarks as a rare admission that the U.S. had a share in creating the problem Pakistan now faces.

She went further in a separate ABC News interview, reported by Deccan Herald, saying the U.S. created the mujahideen force against the Soviet Union, trained it, equipped it and funded it, and that this included Osama bin Laden. Notice the scope of that claim. It is about the -Soviet fighters of the 1980s the anti-Soviet fighters who stood against Soviet power. It does not say Washington built al-Qaeda as an organization or ISIS at all. The ISI in her testimony is Pakistan’s spy agency, and that is worth saying plainly because the acronym gets confused with ISIS.

How a Cold War program fed a jihadist ecosystem

The program behind her remark was Operation Cyclone, the CIA effort to arm and finance the Afghan mujahideen starting in 1979. It began with about $20 million to $30 million each year. Grew to around $630 million, per year by 1987. That makes Operation Cyclone one of the expensive covert operations the agency has ever carried out. Most of the money moved through Pakistan’s ISI. Of the seven Afghan groups Pakistan’s military government backed, four were fundamentalist, and those four received most of the funding.

The U.S. was not alone Saudi Arabia. At times went beyond what Washington did with private donations hitting about $20 million each month at their highest point. In 2018 Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman told the Washington Post that Saudi funding for mosques and madrassas, in countries started because Western allies asked for it. They wanted to stop the Soviets from gaining influence in countries. That is his account, offered by an interested party, but it fits the shape of Clinton’s own remark about Wahhabi fighters being welcome as long as they helped.

Here is the argument at its strongest. Washington did not need to invent a religion or a grievance. It needed a motivated force, and it chose to feed the most ideological parts of one. Under Pakistan’s Zia ul-Haq, Saudi money paid for a boom in madrasas while public spending on education shrank. Analysts at India’s Observer Research Foundation note that Pakistan’s military ruler allowed large flows of Saudi money to start madrasas, and that intelligence agencies of the U.S., Saudi Arabia and Pakistan used them to recruit young men for the Afghan war. When the Soviets left in 1989, the money dropped, the fighters did not disappear, and the infrastructure of training camps, seminaries, weapons and a global network of volunteers was left behind. Clinton’s own account of what followed in Pakistan says the U.S. walked away and left others to clean up.

Iraq and the second act

If the Cold War story is the chapter, the 2003 invasion of Iraq is the second. Most historians of the Islamic State agree that the Islamic State grew out of al-Qaeda in Iraq. That group formed as a reaction, to the U.S. Invasion. The rise of the Islamic State was shaped heavily by the militant Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. Critics of the occupation point to the decision to dissolve the Iraqi army and purge Baathists. That left a large number of armed, humiliated and unemployed men, many of them Sunni, with no stake in the new order. Some of them joined Zarqawi.

The University of Chicago’s Robert Pape has built a career on a related thesis. After studying suicide attacks across the world, he argues that foreign military occupation, far more than religion, drives them, and he has said ISIS was born of the occupation of Iraq. You can see why the American-project reading finds Pape useful.

The people who paid were mostly Muslim

Whatever the origins, the bill has landed on Muslim societies. The U.S. National Counterterrorism Center reported in 2011 that where the religion of terrorism victims could be determined, Muslims accounted for between 82 and 97 percent of deaths over the previous five years. The University of Marylands Global Terrorism Database reported 167,221 deaths linked to terrorism from 2001 to 2015 and 98 percent of those happened outside the U.S. And Western Europe. The database does not track the religion of the victims so these are guesses. The databases own data manager has said that many people killed in countries were targeted because they were soldiers, police officers or just in a public place not because of their religion. So the pattern is clear: Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Nigeria and Syria are, at the top of the lists.

Then there are the wars fought in response. The Costs of War project from Brown University estimates that least 940,000 people died directly in the wars that followed 9/11. In addition between 3.6 and 3.8 million people died because of hunger, disease and broken health systems. That brings the number of deaths to at least 4.5 million. The project also says about 38 million people were forced to leave their homes. The financial cost of these wars is estimated to be, around $8 trillion. Two cautions belong here. Indirect deaths are modeled estimates, and those totals cover violence by every party, not only American forces. The project’s own co-director has said the U.S. is not solely responsible for the damage, while arguing it has a significant obligation to help rebuild.

As, for what the rest of the world thinks about these wars I did not find a recent global survey that gives a clear answer. I would rather admit that than make up a number. What is clear is that the Iraq war in particular is widely seen—by U.S. Intelligence analysts quoted in 2006—as something that increased terrorism of reducing it.

Do Muslims see this, and why does the pushback look so quiet?

I couldn’t find any polling that directly asks Muslims if they think extremism is a project. So anyone giving a number is just guessing. What we have instead are clues. Pakistani news outlets covered Clinton’s testimony in ways and the history of the Afghan jihad is well known in South Asia.

The pointed part of the question assumes Muslims haven’t made a clear intellectual stand against extremism. That assumption is too strong. In 2010 the Pakistani scholar Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri published a 600-page fatwa saying suicide bombing and terrorism have no place in Islam. The Muslim Council of Britain supported it. Before that in 2008 India’s Darul Uloom Deoband issued a ruling.. In 2005 American Muslim jurists did too.

Pew’s 2013 survey of eleven publics found that 67 percent on average were worried about Islamic extremism. In Pakistan 89 percent said suicide bombings against civilians are never justified. In Indonesia it was 81 percent. In Nigeria 78 percent.. In Palestine 62 percent said such attacks are often or sometimes justified. So the views are not the same.. That survey is over ten years old.

What’s true is that these voices don’t often reach an audience. From what I’ve seen part of the problem is built into the system. Many Muslim-majority countries are authoritarian. That means independent think tanks, free press and universities. Places that could push back with arguments. Are under constant pressure.. Some of the groups that support extremism are backed by Muslim-majority governments themselves. So speaking out can be risky, at home.

The science and education gap

The gap in science is real. I do not think it is mainly caused by Washington. A report from the Royal Societys Atlas of Islamic-World Science found that OIC countries with a quarter of the worlds people account for about 2.4 percent of research spending 1.6 percent of patents and 6 percent of scientific publications. On average these countries spend under 0.5 percent of GDP on research against five times that in developed economies. A 2006 Nature analysis noted that six of the ten countries with the military burden relative to public spending were OIC members.

This is not a story of decline. Publications and researchers in OIC countries have roughly tripled in the decade or so before those reports Turkey raised research spending steadily Qatar planned to lift it sharply and Saudi Arabia built KAUST with a very large endowment. These figures are from the mid-2010s and earlier so current numbers will. Anyone using them in a classroom should check for newer releases.

On the education side the link to this topic is direct in one place: under Zia, the expansion of madrasas coincided with a fall in investment in schooling. Money that builds seminaries focused on one worldview of general schools is a choice about modernization and it was a choice encouraged by outside sponsors as well, as made by local rulers. Whether Muslims “want” modernization is the frame. Most families want schools. The obstacle is usually money, governance and conflict.

Islamophobia and the missing narrative

Western Islamophobia is documented, though the data come mostly from advocacy groups and that should be said. The Council on Islamic Relations reported more than 8,000 complaints in its 2024 report, the highest in its thirty-year history and CAIR says 85 percent of incidents go unreported. The FBIs 2023 hate-crime data listed 236 -Muslim incidents. CAIR also counted 33 incidents targeting mosques in 2025 and 17 more between May and July of 2026. Californias Attorney General reported a 58 percent rise in -Muslim hate in the state in 2025 according to CAIRs account of the report.

Why is there no Muslim narrative against it? Partly the answer overlaps with the section media reach, funding and institutional trust are uneven. Partly it is that Muslim communities in the West are small split by sect, ethnicity and politics and often busy with the economic pressures as everyone else. A confident global narrative would need Muslim-led media think tanks and film studios with budgets and that is a development problem as much, as an ideological one.

Do ordinary Muslims have anything to do with extremism?

On the evidence provided, very little in the way that really counts. The large number of people who have been killed are Muslims. In almost every country that was studied the majority of people reject attacks on civilians. Some of the well-known religious leaders have also said this publicly. The Pew data also showed that support for suicide bombing was not really connected to money, education or how religious someone is. Thinking that, than a billion people are connected to the actions of just a few small groups is a mistake and this mistake is what Islamophobia is built on.

Where this argument needs care

Everything that has been said above is the version of the American‑project reading. The case against it or at least against the form is also serious. A fair post must include this.

Historian Steve Coll, in Ghost Wars argues that the CIA did not train or fund the volunteers who later formed al‑qaeda. Funding went to Afghan mujahideen through Pakistan. Pakistans military would not let foreigners operate freely. The Taliban formed in 1994. Years after most of the Cold War funding ended fact‑checkers reject the claim that the CIA funded the Taliban directly.

Hassan Hassan, writing in The Atlantic has argued that the intellectual groundwork for ISIS was laid by jihadists before the 2003 invasion. Papes thesis has been challenged too. Assaf Moghadam argues that occupation explains local suicide campaigns but not the globalized martyrdom of al‑qaeda. Assaf Moghadam also argues that Pape overstated how often these attacks succeed.

Broadly American policy was one actor among several. Pakistans generals chose which groups to back. Saudi Arabia exported Wahhabism for its reasons, including rivalry with Iran. Zarqawi, bin Laden and Baghdadi made their decisions. Saying Washington helped create the conditions is well supported. Saying extremism is more American than Muslim treats millions of Muslims who fought taught, recruited or died as scenery in someone Story. This can excuse the governments, in the region that profited from the arrangement.

Ways out

There is no settled consensus on these points. Each point follows from the evidence.

I think the first point is honesty about the past. Clinton in 2009 said it is possible. Official accounts of Cyclone, Iraq and the drone wars followed by investment in rebuilding the countries that were hit would do more than any speech. The Costs of War researchers say the same.

I believe the second point is to stop supporting the generation of the same bargain. Supporting partners and ideological militias for short‑term gains has a long record of causing the next crisis.

I feel the third point falls to societies themselves. Muslim societies should spend seriously on research and universities as OIC members have pledged, with a plan to double science spending in the countries and reach 2 percent of GDP in the richer ones. Muslim societies should fund media and scholarship that can answer both extremists and Islamophobes in public. Muslim societies should build education that serves families, not patrons. Muslim scholars like Qadri have shown that the theological case against terrorism can be made at length. Muslim societies need an audience and institutions behind it.

I think the fourth point is for everyone stop treating victims as suspects. The people at risk from extremist violence and most affected by the wars fought against it are the same people that Islamophobic rhetoric targets.

Extremism has than one author and the American hand, in it is real, documented and partly admitted by Hillary Clinton. The result is a duty to repair and a duty for societies to build the institutions that make them harder to use.

Sources

– Snopes fact check on Hillary Clinton’s remarks: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/hillary-clinton-created-al-qaeda/

– Dawn, “Clinton admits US role” (April 2009): https://www.dawn.com/news/amp/847153

– Vox Ukraine fact check: https://voxukraine.org/en/false-secretary-of-state-hillary-clinton-stated-that-the-usa-created-al-qaeda

– Deccan Herald on Clinton’s ABC interview: https://www.deccanherald.com/world/pak-used-terror-hedge-against-2528543

– Operation Cyclone overview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Cyclone

– Foreign involvement in the Soviet-Afghan War: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_involvement_in_the_Soviet%E2%80%93Afghan_War

– History of al-Qaeda (citing Steve Coll, Ghost Wars): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_al-Qaeda

– WUSA9 Verify on the Taliban and CIA funding: https://wusa9.com/article/news/verify/no-the-us-government-did-not-directly-fund-the-taliban-fact-check-afghanistan-cia-reagan-carter/65-fa07d053-aa77-4998-ad13-950bc6dc007e

– Tribune, Mohammed bin Salman on Wahhabism funding: https://tribune.com.pk/story/1672777/3?amp=1

– Observer Research Foundation, Pakistani madrasas: https://www.orfonline.org/research/pakistani-madrasas-questions-answers

– Hassan Hassan, “The True Origins of ISIS” (The Atlantic, via Small Wars Journal): https://smallwarsjournal.com/node/110921

– History News Network on de-Baathification and ISIS: https://www.historynewsnetwork.org/article/159589

– Robert Pape, Dying to Win: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dying_to_Win

– Moghadam critique of Pape: https://ideas.repec.org/a/taf/uterxx/v29y2006i8p707-729.html

– RFE/RL on terrorism victims in Muslim-majority countries: https://gandhara.rferl.org/a/terrorism-muslim-majority-countries/27949500.html

– Tempo/BBC on NCTC figures: https://en.tempo.co/amp/636545/most-victims-of-terrorism-are-muslims-imam-says

– Al Jazeera, human cost of 25 years of US wars (Costs of War figures): https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/longform/2026/9/11/everything-changed-the-human-cost-of-25-years-of-us-wars

– Scheerpost on the Costs of War indirect deaths report: https://scheerpost.com/2023/05/16/death-outlives-war-analysis-estimates-post-9-11-us-conflicts-killed-over-4-5-million/

– Pew Research Center, 2013 survey of Muslim publics: https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2013/09/10/muslim-publics-share-concerns-about-extremist-groups/

– Foreign Policy on Tahir-ul-Qadri’s fatwa: https://foreignpolicy.com/2010/04/14/sheikh-to-terrorists-go-to-hell/

– Royal Society, Atlas of Islamic-World Science and Innovation: https://waftest2.royalsociety.org/-/media/policy/projects/atlas-islamic-world/atlas-final-report.pdf

– Nature, “Science in the Muslim world”: https://www.nature.com/articles/444026a

– ABC7 on CAIR’s 2024 civil rights report: https://abc7news.com/us-facing-worst-wave-of-anti-muslim-bigotry-in-30-years-cair-annual-report/14608265/

– Anadolu Agency on CAIR mosque incident data: https://aa.com.tr/en/world/us-muslim-group-documents-183-increase-in-mosque-incidents-over-same-period-last-year/4011901

– CAIR-CA on California’s 2025 hate crime report: https://www.cair.com/?p=77637