Thursday, November 19, 2026
snpick
Analysis

Americas War Economy: Who Gains From Permanent War?

a
admin
October 23, 2026 • Updated 4:27 PM • 8 min read
Americas War Economy
Illustration: snpick

Every years Washington says the world has never been this dangerous and every few years the defense budget rises. In 2025 America spent about $954 billion on its military according to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI). That was a dip and SIPRI expects it to be short‑lived. Congress has approved than $1 trillion for 2026 and a proposal on the table would raise it to $1.5 trillion in 2027.

That is the backdrop for what people call America’s war economy: a setup where government, arms companies and foreign policy’re so tangled that fighting wars or preparing for them becomes part of how the economy runs. I want to work through five questions that I keep seeing about America’s war economy. I relied on the Stimson Center’s essay on the ” war economy ” Wikipedia’s overview and recent data and reporting. One caution before we begin: many of the critics I mention such as the Quincy Institute and Cato want a militarized foreign policy so I have tried to include the other side’s case wherever it exists.

What is a war economy?
Wikipedia describes a war economy as the steps a state takes to mobilize its economy for war production with more planning, rationing and conscription. The American textbook case is World War II, when two thirds of the economy had been pulled into the war effort by the end of 1943. The same page mentions ” Keynesianism,” the idea that military budgets can smooth out recessions and it notes that America has been in a continuous state of war since the September 11 attacks.

Stimson argues that a mobilization meant to be temporary has become permanent. National security spending has grown 50 % since 2000 and the Pentagon budget is closing in on a trillion dollars.

Why does America get involved in wars?
There is no answer and anyone who gives you one is probably selling something. I see three layers. The first layer is strategy. For decades leaders in both parties have believed that alliances and forward‑deployed forces keep the peace and that armed intervention is sometimes needed to stop terrorism or civil conflict. Scholars at the Cato Institute call this “primacy”. Argue it tempts policymakers to use force even when core America interests are not at stake. Defenders reply that deterrence is cheaper than a great‑power war. A Senate‑created commission in 2024 called the security environment the dangerous since World War II and Senator Roger Wicker proposed raising defense spending to at least 5 % of GDP.

The second layer is institutional. Stimson says the Pentagon’s core problem is strategy, which more money can’t fix and he calls the result strategic overreach. Meanwhile the money flows to the companies that build the weapons. From 2020 to 2024 private firms received $2.4 trillion in Pentagon contracts 54 % of discretionary spending up from 41 % in the 1990s. Five companies—Lockheed Martin, RTX, Boeing, General Dynamics and Northrop Grumman—took $771 billion of it. Weapons makers have also spent around $2.5 billion on lobbying over two decades. None of that proves lobbying starts wars. It does mean plenty of well‑funded people do well when the answer to “what should we do?” is military.

Eisenhower worried about this in 1961 when he warned about the “military‑industrial complex.” The third layer is a belief that war spending’s good for the economy. I will come back to it because the evidence is shakier than the slogan.

What influence does America have on the war in the Middle East?
A great deal, though not unlimited. From October 2023 to September 2025 America gave Israel at $21.7 billion in military aid according to Brown University’s Costs of War project and the Quincy Institute. America spent another $9.65 to $12.07 billion on operations in Yemen and the wider region for a total of roughly $31 to $34 billion. Earlier Brown research found Israel has received America military aid than any country in history about $251 billion, in inflation‑adjusted dollars since 1959.

In 2026 the United States changed from supplier to combatant. ABC News reports that the war with Iran started in February with American and Israeli strikes. The two sides signed a memorandum of understanding in June. Talks have stalled. The United States says the United States is enforcing a blockade on ships while Iran claims control of the Strait of Hormuz and continues to claim attacks on shipping. This week NPR reported that Washington and Israel are preparing plans for strikes after the United States midterm elections. The Council on Foreign Relations citing the Financial Times says Donald Trump opposed a plan to restart the war before the election. In Gaza the Times of Israel says the United States‑led push for a deal, in which Hamas disarms and Israel withdraws has stalled. I see supporters say this policy protects an ally and checks Iran. I hear critics say this policy deepens the conflicts it aims to contain. Either way the Middle East is where the war economy is most visible: the aid, the arms sales and the deployments all feed each other.

What role is foreign policy playing in Europes instability?
I think the obvious is that Russia invaded Ukraine and that is the cause. The harder question is whether three decades of United States policy made Europe more or less stable and serious people disagree.

I recall that a group of officials warned that NATO enlargement would draw a new line between “ins” and “outs” in Europe. A recent Cato paper goes further. Calls NATO enlargement a net loss for United States security. On the side supporters argued that NATO enlargement widened the zone of stability and Joe Biden then a senator said the dire predictions about Russia had not come true. Political scientist Paul van Hooft offers a view: NATO enlargement did stabilize Central and Eastern Europe but United States policy also made sure no rival European security arrangement could compete with NATO, which diluted European strategic cohesion and stretched European militaries thin.

What is not in dispute is the result. Europe is rearming at a pace not seen in decades. SIPRI says European military spending rose 14% in 2025 to $864 billion and arms imports more than tripled between the two most recent five‑year periods. Much of that shopping list is American. Instability in Europe has become, among things a sales opportunity.

What has America gained from the war in Ukraine?
Less than the slogans on either side suggest. More than nothing. Start with the money. According to figures reported by Voice of America Congress appropriated about $183 billion for Ukraine the Pentagon confirmed that $65.9 billion of that went out as military aid and roughly $58 billion was spent inside the United States. That money paid for United States‑made weapons to replace old ones sent to Kyiv, new purchases and factory investment. Donald Trump’s repeated claim of $350 billion is not backed by those records. The Kiel Institute estimates that Europe has allocated about $140 billion in aid to Ukraine compared with United States $120 billion.

Then the sales. SIPRI found United States arms exports to Europe jumped 233% between 2015‑19 and 2020‑24 and Europe now takes 35% of United States arms exports up from 13%. Ukraine alone accounted for 26% of United States exports to Europe and 71% of those transfers were second‑hand weapons pulled from stockpiles. That last figure is the sweet spot for Washington: old equipment leaves the warehouse and new equipment gets ordered. Since 2025 the model has shifted. SIPRI notes that Washington approved no Ukraine aid that year and Europe stepped in through PURL, a NATO–United States mechanism where allies pay for United States weapons that go to Kyiv. At 25 countries joined in 2025 and NATO chief Mark Rutte has said that the program will amount to, about $15 billion in 2026. The Kiel Institute estimates that Europe’s new military aid is up 67% while new United States support has fallen 99%. Energy is part of the picture too. The European Union spent €277 billion on liquefied natural gas between 2021 and mid‑2025 and American suppliers took a growing share. So United States taxpayers paid, United States firms and a few industries collected and whether the strategic payoff justifies the bill is a judgment call. People land on both sides of it.

What does America gain by getting involved in wars?
It depends on who “United States” means. The gains are concentrated. The costs are spread out. The clearest winners are contractors. A 2023 Pentagon study, cited by Stimson found that traded military contractors increased the cash paid to shareholders by seventy‑three percent between the 2000s and the 2010s while cutting investment and research spending. Lockheed Martin drew seventy‑three percent of its 2023 sales from US government contracts and the F‑35 alone made up twenty‑six percent. Over the post‑9/11 wars eight trillion dollars went to just the top five firms.

Then there is the jobs argument. Stimson answers that any large government spending stimulates growth that other industries create jobs per dollar and that research suggests that military spending drags on long run growth in most countries. It also cites economist Alexander Fields argument that even World War II mobilization hurt term American growth by distorting investment. Wikipedia lays out the view: wars can speed up technological progress and strengthen an economy afterward especially one spared the destruction. That debate is not settled.

Now the costs. Browns Costs of War project estimates that the post‑9/11 wars have cost about eight trillion dollars with US operations and programs in at least seventy‑eight countries as of 2023 and an estimated three point six to three point eight million indirect deaths in the war zones. Much of that money was borrowed. In 2024 Stimson notes that interest payments on the debt exceeded the Pentagons base budget for the first time.

Supporters add benefits that no ledger captures: deterrence, alliances and the argument that a war that never happens is the point of the budget. That is an argument and it is hard to prove or disprove either way.

So who wins?
If you follow the money the beneficiaries are easy to name: a handful of defense companies governments that receive weapons and protection and communities that host the factories. The bill goes to taxpayers, future taxpayers and to the people who live in the places where the wars are fought. The strongest defense of the system is that security cannot be priced like a product. The strongest critique is that nobody has to demonstrate that the spending purchases the security it promises. Which of those you find convincing probably depends on how dangerous you think the world is.

Sources

– War economy Wikipedia
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_economy)

– The Ugly Truth about the Permanent War Economy, Stimson Center (2024)
(https://www.stimson.org/2024/the-truth-about-the-permanent-war-economy/)

– Global military spending rise continues, SIPRI (April 2026)
(https://www.sipri.org/node/7856)

 (https://costsofwar.watson.brown.edu/paper/profits-war-top-beneficiaries-pentagon-spending-2020-2024)

 (https://costsofwar.watson.brown.edu/paper/profits-war-beneficiaries-post-911-pentagon-spending-surge)

– Military. Arms Transfers to Israel Oct 2023-Sep 2025 Quincy Institute
(https://quincyinst.org/research/u-s-military-aid-and-arms-transfers-to-israel-october-2023-september-2025/)

– US spends than $20bn in aid to Israel Middle East conflicts Al Jazeera
(https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/10/7/us-spends-more-than-20bn-in-aid-to-israel-middle-east-conflicts-report)

– Iran live updates ABC News (Oct 22 2026)
(https://abcnews.com/International/updates/iran-live-updates/?id=137370653)

– US and Israel are planning for a post-midterms attack on Iran, NPR
(https://npr.org/2026/10/22/nx-s1-6011514/us-israel-iran-war)

– Conflict With Iran Council on Foreign Relations
(https://www.cfr.org/conflict-tracker/conflict/confrontation-between-united-states-and-iran)

– Liveblog, October 22 2026 Times of Israel
(https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog-october-22-2026/)

– Has NATO Enlargement Enhanced US National Security? Cato Institute
(https://www.cato.org/commentary/has-nato-enlargement-enhanced-us-security.md)

– The Debate Over NATO Expansion, Arms Control Association (1997)
(https://www.armscontrol.org/act/1997-09/features/debate-, over-nato-expansion-critique-clinton-administrations-responses-key)    

– Experts Argue For And Against NATO Expansion RFE/RL (1997)
(https://www.rferl.org/amp/1086780.html)

– Land rush: grand strategy, NATO enlargement and European fragmentation – Paul van Hooft, MIT Security Studies Program
(https://ssp.mit.edu/publications/2020/land-rush)

– US figures do not support Trump claims on Ukraine spending – Voice of America (https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/news/ukraine/2025/02/ukraine-250219-voa04.htm)

– US arms exports to Europe triple boosted by Ukraine aid – SIPRI (https://www.yahoo.com/news/us-arms-exports-europe-triple-114844863.html)

– Is the West still around? How much Ukraine will receive in 2026 – Ukrainska Pravda (https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/articles/2026/02/27/8023170)

– weapons will be coming, NATO Secretary General (PURL, 2026) – UkraNews (https://ukranews.com/en/amp/news/1134638-american-weapons-will-be-coming-nato-secretary-general-announces-amount-of-money-for-which-us-will)

– “Peace” as a business: how much the US earns from the war in Europe – Geostrategy (https://geostrategy.org.ua/en/media/articles/mir-yak-biznes-skilki-ssha-zaroblyayut-na-viyni-v-ievropi)

– The True Costs of the Post‑9/11 Wars – Costs of War, Brown University (https://costsofwar.watson.brown.edu/overview)

– Eisenhower’s Farewell Address – History.com
(https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/eisenhower-warns-of-the-military-industrial-complex)

– The Case for Restraint, in U.S. Foreign Policy – Cato Institute
(https://www.cato.org/events/case-restraint-us-foreign-policy)